The New York Rangers on Friday hired Mike Sullivan as their new head coach following his current parting of the way with the Pittsburgh Penguins.
Even earlier than the hiring, many analysts appeared to be in lockstep that the previous Rangers assistant is a perfect rent for a group trying to rebound from an terrible marketing campaign. Nevertheless, is Sullivan actually a slam-dunk alternative?
Sullivan has been an unequivocal success as a head coach, with a pair of Stanley Cups with Pittsburgh in 2016 and 2017 in addition to division titles with the Penguins and with Boston again in 2004. However these successes aren’t precisely current. The not too long ago fired Peter Laviolette has a Stanley Cup, three Finals losses and 5 division titles to his identify. These baubles didn’t actually assist him a lot this previous season, did they?
The 57-year-old Sullivan doesn’t have an entire lot of current success to lean on, both. His Penguins have didn’t make the Stanley Cup playoffs up to now three seasons — their final playoff look was a first-round loss to the Rangers after main the collection 3-1 — ending seventh within the Metro division this previous season.
In actual fact, Sullivan has only a single playoff collection win since hoisting the chalice. It was a first-round win in 2018, the season after his final Stanley Cup win. For these not of a mathematical inclination, which means Sullivan has zero playoff collection wins up to now seven seasons.
Regardless of boasting a roster with first-ballot Corridor of Famers in Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang, in addition to some critically high-end supporting expertise together with Jake Guentzel, Phil Kessel, Bryan Rust, Erik Karlsson and Brian Dumoulin, Sullivan has confirmed unable to craft a bunch that might persistently problem the perfect within the NHL. Sure, it’s honest to place a few of that on former Penguins common supervisor Jim Rutherford and people who have adopted his tenure within the large chair, however Sullivan actually hasn’t overachieved.
In actual fact, it may be argued that even his cup victories might largely be attributed to the work finished by Dan Bylsma, who molded the Penguins’ gifted core right into a championship-level roster earlier than being let go in 2014.
The Rangers have a raft of kids important to their current and future in Will Cuylle, Alexis Lafreniere, Braden Schneider, Brett Berard, Brennan Othmann and Gabe Perreault. Does Sullivan boast any vital observe report of turning kids oozing with potential into stars? Sure, Guentzel instantly involves thoughts, however is there anyone else? Rust would possibly qualify. Matt Murray, maybe? It’s not an awesome roll name.
GM Chris Drury was a participant with the Rangers when Sullivan was an assistant over 15 years in the past. The 2 actually have a fantastic relationship, which isn’t any unhealthy factor. However is that this one other play-it-safe rent?
If Drury will get this teaching rent fallacious, he absolutely received’t get one other one. In that gentle, it’s comprehensible that he checked out Sullivan as a trusted, regular hand. However did he miss the forest for the bushes?
