A South Carolina choose denied Alex Murdaugh’s movement to dismiss his indictments on fees alleging he murdered his spouse and son.
Murdaugh sought to throw out the case as he faces a retrial, after the South Carolina Supreme Court docket overturned his 2023 murder convictions as a result of jury interference. His spouse, Margaret “Maggie” Murdaugh, 52, and youthful son, Paul Murdaugh, 22, had been discovered lifeless from a number of gunshot wounds on the household’s searching property in 2021.
Choose Debra McCaslin issued her resolution on Friday, clearing the way in which for the retrial set for subsequent yr.
Alex Murdaugh listens as his attorneys current a movement throughout a judicial listening to, Nov. 13, 2026, in Lexington, S.C.
Tracy Glantz/Pool/The State through AP
The protection had accused the then-lead state investigator of giving deceptive testimony to the Colleton County grand jury about blood spatter on Murdaugh’s shirt and ammunition recovered from the household’s property the place the murders occurred.
In her order, McCaslin mentioned the protection did not show there was any “intentional prosecutorial or investigative misconduct” that compromised the integrity of the grand jury proceedings.
The choose discovered that the document didn’t present that any proof was fabricated or that “false testimony was knowingly introduced to the grand jury,” in response to the order. Even when the challenged testimony regarding the shirt and ammunition had been excluded from consideration by the grand jury, “the remaining unchallenged proof overwhelmingly established possible trigger,” she wrote.
Throughout a listening to final week on their movement earlier than the choose, the protection alleged that Murdaugh’s indictments had been primarily based on false testimony to the Colleton County grand jury by the chief investigator, former State Regulation Enforcement Division agent David Owen.
Whereas there isn’t a transcript of the Colleton County grand jury session, protection lawyer Jim Griffin referred to Owen’s personal statements in addition to testimony on the unique trial to say the investigator knowingly misled the grand jury concerning sure proof.
Griffin claimed Owen advised the grand jury that there was blood spatter on Murdaugh’s shirt on the night time of the homicide when there was none. He additionally claimed that Owen inaccurately acknowledged that weapons discovered on the property had the identical load because the ammunition used to kill Paul.
Whereas testifying through the trial, Owen confirmed that he advised the grand jury that an knowledgeable discovered a number of particles of blood spatter on Murdaugh’s shirt, and that he hadn’t seen a report that discovered no human blood on the shirt till after Murdaugh had been indicted. Owen additionally testified through the trial that he inaccurately advised the grand jury that different firearms on the Murdaugh property had been loaded in a similar way to the shotgun used to kill Paul. He mentioned he wasn’t attempting to trick grand jurors.
Prosecutor Creighton Waters discounted the protection’s arguments throughout final week’s listening to, saying that on the time of the grand jury testimony, the claims concerning the splatter on the shirt had been believed to be true. Waters additionally introduced proof that he mentioned discounted Griffin’s assertion that there was no different weapon on the home that had the identical shot-load because the one used to kill Paul.
Moreover, Waters argued there was rather more compelling proof that may have been introduced to the grand jury that may have been thought of. For example, he introduced up a video discovered on Paul’s cellular phone that he mentioned had audio of Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh collectively simply moments earlier than the killings.

Alex Murdaugh grimaces as his lawyer describes his son’s blood spatter, throughout a judicial listening to, Nov. 13, 2026, in Lexington, S.C.
Tracy Glantz/Pool/The State through AP
Preparations have been underway for Murdaugh to face trial for the homicide of his spouse and son once more subsequent yr.
His retrial has been set for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County, after McCaslin granted a change of venue.
Prosecutors mentioned they had been ready to hunt one other set of grand jury indictments as quickly as subsequent month, ought to the protection reach dismissing the unique indictments.
Throughout final week’s listening to, McCaslin requested the prosecution in the event that they might be able to resubmit to the grand jury throughout their Dec. 10 session in time to go forward with the April 5, 2027, trial, ought to they reach getting a brand new indictment. Waters mentioned he’d be prepared.
The South Carolina Supreme Court docket overturned Murdaugh’s 2023 murder convictions and life sentences earlier this yr — citing “surprising jury interference” by the court docket clerk within the Colleton County trial.
Murdaugh stays in jail after pleading responsible to separate monetary crimes. He was sentenced to 27 years on state fees and 40 years on federal fees for the monetary crimes.
The disgraced lawyer admitted to stealing from his shoppers, although he has denied killing his spouse and son.
