Lindsay Clancy’s legal professionals are asking Massachusetts’ highest courtroom to throw out her triple homicide case forward of her March 2027 retrial.
Clancy, whose attorneys mentioned she was affected by postpartum psychosis on the time, pleaded not responsible to a few counts of first-degree homicide in reference to the deaths of her three kids on the household’s dwelling in Duxbury, Massachusetts, in January 2023.
Her first trial was declared a mistrial in September after the jury mentioned it couldn’t attain a unanimous verdict following seven days of deliberations.
In courtroom papers filed earlier this week, Clancy’s legal professionals renewed their argument that the decide who oversaw the case improperly declared a mistrial with out questioning the holdout juror about whether or not he had cheap doubt in regards to the guilt of the Massachusetts mom.
Lindsay Clancy seems in courtroom throughout her homicide trial in Plymouth Superior Court docket, Nov. 16, 2026, in Plymouth, Mass.
Greg Derr/Pool by way of AP
“Respectfully, opposite to the trial courtroom’s said perception on the time, it did have viable selections apart from declaring a mistrial,” Clancy’s legal professionals argued of their attraction to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court docket.
Clancy’s legal professionals appealed a choice from Choose William Sullivan final week rejecting their movement to dismiss on double jeopardy grounds. Days after issuing that ruling, Choose Sullivan scheduled her retrial to start on March 29. Prosecutors haven’t explicitly mentioned what costs they’ll pursue however advised it will be the identical first-degree homicide costs she confronted throughout her preliminary trial.
“I really feel unhealthy for Lindsay. I really feel unhealthy for her household. I really feel unhealthy for the jurors that have not been picked but. I really feel unhealthy for everyone that has something to do with this case. It’s totally emotional, it’s totally distressing, however nonetheless we bought to get it achieved,” protection lawyer Kevin Reddington mentioned outdoors the courtroom on Monday after prosecutors mentioned they’d pursue a retrial.

Clancy lawyer Kevin Reddington listens to prosecutor Jennifer Sprague say that she is able to retry the case towards his consumer, Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts girl whose trial on homicide costs for killing her three kids led to a mistrial in September, in Plymouth Superior Court docket in Plymouth, Massachusetts, US, November 2, 2026.
Greg Derr/the Patriot Ledger/by way of Reuters
Clancy’s legal professionals requested a single justice of the appeals courtroom to carry oral arguments, then report the difficulty to the total courtroom for consideration. Appeals of first-degree homicide instances in Massachusetts immediately go to the Supreme Judicial Court docket, bypassing the state’s mid-level courtroom.
“Any successive trial, at present scheduled to start on March 29, 2027, would violate Ms. Clancy’s Double Jeopardy rights,” Clancy’s legal professionals argued.
Of their 55-page attraction, Clancy’s legal professionals argued that the result of questioning the holdout juror — whether or not it will have led to his elimination or not modified the result of the case — doesn’t matter, and that the query earlier than the courtroom is whether or not the trial decide erroneously declined a viable possibility.
“With out inquiry, there can solely be guesswork, which doesn’t fulfill the excessive normal of manifest necessity,” they wrote.
Earlier than a mistrial was declared in September, her protection lawyer Kevin Reddington filed a last-minute emergency attraction to the identical courtroom, which declined to intervene.
Clancy’s retrial is scheduled to start on March 29. Her legal professionals have vowed to not search a keep of the case throughout their attraction, partially to make sure the case is heard by the identical decide earlier than he retires.
